Goodie House Pizza

Discover delicious pizza at Goodie House Pizza in Sullivan, IN. Enjoy our flavorful breadsticks, stromboli, and savory sausage in a cozy dining area. Call +1 812-268-6841 for a satisfying meal today!

Welcome to Goodie House Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Goodie House Pizza
Goodie House Pizza
Goodie House Pizza
Goodie House Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Sullivan, Indiana, Goodie House Pizza serves as a culinary haven for pizza lovers and sandwich enthusiasts alike. Customers flock to this cozy spot at 8 N Main St, drawn by the tantalizing scents of baked breadsticks and savory stromboli wafting through the air. With a menu featuring a rich array of pizzas, specialty items, and mouthwatering sides, there's something to satisfy every craving.

The inviting atmosphere makes it the perfect spot for family dinners, casual meet-ups, or a quick bite on the go. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this pizza place not only fills stomachs but also fosters a warm community spirit.

Location & Contact

Address

8 N Main St, Sullivan, IN 47882, United States

Phone

+1 812-268-6841

About

Goodie House Pizza
Goodie House Pizza
Goodie House Pizza
Goodie House Pizza

Goodie House Pizza has carved out a special place in the hearts of Sullivan residents since it opened its doors. This establishment focuses on providing not just food but an experience where taste meets comfort. The variety on the menu showcases the kitchen's creativity; from traditional Italian pizza recipes to innovative desserts, every item has a story to tell. The well-loved menu includes 14 types of pizzas, offering both fan-favorites and limited-time specials. This combination of tradition and innovation ensures that customers return to try something new with every visit.

Additionally, the dedication to quality ingredient sourcing is evident in their crust, which stands as a hallmark of achievement.

Customers rave about the perfect balance of crunchy and chewy, providing that ideal bite every pizza aficionado looks for. The restaurant’s sandwiches round out the fare, with hearty options that can satisfy even the most discerning palate. After enjoying a savory meal, guests often indulge in heavenly dessert options like the Triple Chocolate Cake Slice or a creative Cookie Pizza, ending their meals on a sweet note.

Goodie House Pizza's charm extends to its vibrant community involvement.

They frequently engage in events that promote local culture and foster neighborhood relationships. Whether it’s a community fundraising night or support for school sports events, good food and good company take center stage, reinforcing the establishment's mission to be a place where food and community come together. From birthday parties to casual family dinners or late-night takeout, Goodie House Pizza promises a resilient bond built around shared meals.

Work Hours

  • Sunday4-8:30 PM
  • Monday4-8:30 PM
  • Tuesday4-8:30 PM
  • Wednesday4-8:30 PM
  • Thursday4-8:30 PM
  • Friday4-9 PM
  • Saturday4-9 PM

Goodie House Pizza excels in delivering quality and variety. The menu boasts a staggering 46 dishes, catering to all tastes. From classic pizzas like the Supreme and Texas BBQ to unique offerings such as Dessert Pizza and Low Carb Pizza Bowls, each dish invites you to explore new flavors.

The restaurant shines with its appetizers, especially the loaded breadsticks and the famous Bosco sticks, appealing to both the young and the young at heart.

For those wanting a heartier meal, the selection of sandwiches—including the hearty Meatball Sub and savory Ham & Cheese—are must-tries. An impressive drink selection pairs perfectly with each meal, featuring Pepsi fountain drinks and refreshing soda options. This attention to detail sets Goodie House Pizza apart, making it a go-to dining spot in Sullivan.

Goodie House Pizza

From the outside, Goodie House Pizza presents an unpretentious charm. The brick façade welcomes you in, while bright signage beckons those seeking a delicious meal. Within, the atmosphere radiates warmth and friendliness. The rustic decor frames the dining area, setting the stage for memorable dining experiences. The establishment often buzzes with chatter, laughter, and the smells of pizza cooking in the oven. It radiates a homely vibe that invites patrons to linger a little longer and savor their meals while enjoying each other's company.

Customer Reviews

I really liked how polite they were tonight. I definitely recommend to be honest. I will come again definitely! (The baked spaghetti is very nice it doesn't have a tough upper layer and I love it!!)

S
Shiloh_Low

I hadn't been here since the 90s and I was pleasantly surprised with the food and the great service, the waitress we had, Hayleigh, took great care of us tonight, we will definitely be coming back again!

M
Mark C.

Delicious pizza and great atmosphere!

K
Kelsie R.

One of our very favorite pizza places of all time! We have not had the opportunity to dine in, but we always order for pickup and it never disappoints! If you have ywt to try this pizza, you are missing out! The bread sticks are amazing too! (We always ask for our pizza cut in squares, I know it's crazy...but I swear it taste even better)

A
Ashley S.

Amazing pizza. They were a little busy with cary outs and did not have drink station set up when we arrived, but our server was very attentive to our needs.

c
chris g.

We got the Inferno Pizza, extra spicy! So good! Not for the faint of heart, but we powered through it. The staff was incredibly nice, and clearly always looking for ways to improve. I would highly recommend them any time.

M
Max W.